Monday, 13 October 2014

Ghadeer & Imam Mahdi (ATFS)

Indeed ghadeer is the greatest eid for the believers as said by our sixth imam,  Hazrat Jafar ibne mohammed (a.s ) - this is the greatest eid from the side of Allah. HE has not raised any prophet but they have considered this day as eid.
Tehzib ul ahkam volume 3 page 143
We shias who take this day as the greatest eid and celebrate in it,  do we understand our responsibilities towards this most important incident?  Do we realize that the believers of the last time were also addressed by the holy Prophet sawa on 18th zilhaj 10 AH?  Do we know towards which bayat have we been invited since that day of ghadeer?
As per the instructions of imam sadiq a.s the day of ghadeer is called as يوم العهد و المعهود - the day of promise of promised one
And in the earth is called as يوم الميثاق المأخوذ
The day of the undertaken promise.
That covenant and promise which the people of heaven and earth recognize due to gadhir,  is which covenant?  
Is it not the same promise for which Allah the Almighty has said in surah baqarah:40 - that you fulfill My promise?  Has imam sadiq a.s not said that: we are the promise of Allah then whoever fulfills our promise fulfills the promise of Allah. Kafi volume 1 page 221 tradition 3.
The only remnant of this promise who is still alive on the surface of this earth is the same imam for who's ziyarat we say
السلام عليك يا ميثاق الله الذي أخذه و وكده
He Is our last master who on the day of ghadeer was introduced by name and his attributes and his master-ship was also made obligatory upon the people.
But it is a regret that majority of the masses and even some of his shias do not know about this covenant,  and are unaware of the method of doing his bayat. Thus from this aspect it is necessary upon us to continuously increase our recognition of the promise of gadheer so that we can fulfill it in the best possible manner. 

Let us now looks at the conditions of this covenant that the Holy Prophet (sawa) took from people on the day of Ghadeer:

Oh people indeed Ali is your Imam after me and is my successor upon you. He is my successor, my vazir, my brother and the husband of my daughter and the father of my sons and is the possessor of shafaet and Hawz and my flag barer. Any one who denies him has denied me. And any one who denies me has denied Allah (AJ). Any one who agrees with his Imamat has agreed upon my Prophethood, and anyone who agrees with my Prophet-hood has accepted the tawheed of Allah.

Oh People whoever disobeys Ali  has disobeyed me and any one who has disobeyed me has disobeyed Allah (aj).  And any one who has obeyed Ali has obeyed me and any one who obeyed me has obeyed Allah.

Oh people any one who by his words or deeds opposes Ali has opposed me and any one who has opposed me has opposed Allah (aj)

Oh people anyone  who appoints anyone as an Imam in the place of Ali (a.s) surely he has placed some one in my place of prophet-hood, and any one who has selected some one other than me in the place of prophet-hood has appointed a God in place of Allah (aj)...

If we ponder in the above portion of the sermon of Ghadeer it becomes transparent to us that someone who has not accepted Ali (a.s) and the rightful successors of the Holy Prophet (sawa) as the Imam then his prophet-hood and Tawheed is also incorrect, then there remains no scope of just 5% difference between us and those who deny the imamamt of the rightful Imamas (a.s).

Whatever the Holy Prophet (sawa) has said concerning Ali (a.s) and the covenant towards him holds true for all the Imams (a.s) from his progeny till the day of judgement. And anyone who wishes to fulfill this covenant in any era should be able to accomplish it.  After pronouncing the above mentioned conditions of the covenant, the Prophet (sawa) explained the verse of Quran thus:

ايها الناس اوفوا بعهد الله في علي يوف لكم في الجنة يوم القيامة

Oh people fulfill the covenant of Allah concerning Ali (a.s) he shall fulfill for you the promise of paradise on the day of judgement

When we compare these conditions along with the statement of the Holy Prophet (sawa) concerning the domain of this covenant, it becomes clear that this covenant is for all the people till the day of judgement, that they fulfill their promise of Imamat:

 وقد بلغت ما امرت بتبليغه حجة على كل حاضر وغائب وعلى كل احد ممن شهد او لم يشهد ولد او لم يولد فليبلغ الحاضر الغائب والوالد الولد الى يوم القيامة

"and certainly I have informed what I was  commanded concerning its message, it is an argument upon all present and absent and upon everyone who testified or did not testify, born or yet to be born, then those who are present should inform those absent and fathers should inform the children till the day of judgement…"

Thus this passing of the information of Ghadeer to the generations to come and to all others present in our time is a responsibility on every one who has heard this message as per the command of the Holy Prophet (sawa), and any type of deviation in this command would result in no actions being accepted as per the verse of Quran the ayate balligh…

Thus it becomes necessary upon us to pass on the message of true Imamat of even the Imam of our time as evident from the sermon of Ghadir:

الا ان خاتم الائمة منا القائم المهدي

Know that surely the Last of the Imams from us is the Qaim Al-Mahdi

 الا انه ولي الله في ارضه وحكمه في خلقه وامينه في سره وعلانيته

Know that he is the wali of Allah on His earth and is His Judge on His creatures and is His trustee for His secrets and His announcements

Lastly we close our discussion by quoting two points from the sermon of ghdeer:

  1. Rejecting even one Imam from the Ahlebayt is like rejecting all the Imams:
فمن شك في ذلك فهو كافر كفر الجاهلية الاولي، ومن شك في شيء من قولي هذا فقد شك في الكل منه



  1. It is obligatory upon every person to give his bayat to the Aimmah (a.s) by accepting this message of Ghadeer, even in this time and in every time
فأمرت ان اخذ البيعة منكم والصفقة لكم بقبول ما جئت به عن الله عزوجل


Friday, 25 October 2013

Tradition of Ghadeer is reliable as per the Scholars of Ahle Sunnah

For those Muslim brothers who blindly without any evaluation say that Hadithe Ghadeer is a weak tradition, we would like to gift them with 12 references of Ahle Sunnat authors who upon their research on the topic of Ghadeer conclude that Hadithe Ghadeer is a mutawatir tradition. Mutawatir is terminologically used for those traditions that have been narrated through various different chains, such that there remains no doubt in the authenticity of the tradition. And every Muslim should know that a mutawatir tradition is just like the verse of Quran from the aspect of correctness and belief. What I mean here is that just like no Muslim can continue to be a Muslim by denying a single verse of the Holy Quran similar is the case with tradiotions of Holy Prophet (sawa). No one can continue to claim Islam yet deny the words of the respected Prophet (sawa). we back this from the verse of Holy Quran where Allah Mighty and Majestic be He says in Surah Hashr verse number 7:

وَمَآ ءَاتَٮٰكُمُ ٱلرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَہَٮٰكُمۡ عَنۡهُ فَٱنتَهُواْ‌ۚ

whatever the messenger (sawa) gives you then you take it and whatever he prohibits you from then you refrain.

Let us now inspect a list of authors that consider this tradition of Ghadeer from the Holy Prophet (sawa) to be correct and reliable.

1) Shamsuddin Zahabi (exp 748 AH)



vقلت: جمع (طبري) طرق حديث غدير خم في أربعة أجزاء رأيت شطره فبهرني سعة رواياته وجزمت بوقوع ذلك .

 سير أعلام النبلاء ، ج 14 ، ص 277 

I say: Tabari has collected the hadithe Ghadeer khum in four aspects I have inspected it then the amplitude of its narration dazzled me and I affirm the occurrence of this incident.


2) Ibne Hajar Askalani (exp 852 AH)

¡واما حديث «من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه» فقد أخرجه الترمذي والنسائي وهو كثير الطرق جداً وقد استوعبها بن عقدة في كتاب مفرد وكثير من اسانيدها صحاح وحسان .
فتح الباري شرح صحيح البخاري ، ج 7 ، ص 74

As for the tradition "Of whomsover I am the master then Ali is his master", then certainly it is narrated by Tirmizi and Nisaii and it really has many chains of narrators. And certainly bin ukbah in his book Mufrad has broughtforth it through many chains of narration that are correct and accurate



3) Ibne Hajar Haithami (Exp 974 AH)

أنه حديث صحيح لا مرية فيه وقد أخرجه جماعة كالترمذي والنسائي وأحمد و طرقه كثيرة جدا ومن ثم رواه ستة عشر صحابيا وفي رواية لأحمد أنه سمعه من النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ثلاثون صحابيا وشهدوا به لعلي لما نوزع أيام خلافته كما مر وسيأتي وكثير من أسانيدها صحاح وحسان ولا التفات لمن قدح في صحته .
الصواعق المحرقه ، ج 1 ، ص 106ـ 107
Surely it is a correct tradition there is no doubt in it and certainly it has been narrted by a group of the likes of Tirmizi, Nisaii, Ahmad and its chains are really excessive. And it is said to have been narrated from 16 companions and in the narration of Ahmad, surely it has been heard from the Prophet (sawa) from 30 companions and they have testified to Ali when he (a.s) called them during his days of khilafat as it has passed. And soon we shall bring a long list of chain of narrators that are reliable and good and there is no way out for the one who slanders its reliability.


 4) Jalaluddin Suyuti (exp 911 AH)

vالمناوي: (من كنت مولاه)... ورجال أحمد ثقات بل قال المؤلف (جامع الصغير): حديث متواتر .

التيسير بشرح الجامع الصغير ، ج 2   ص 442


Al Manawi says:  (of whomsoever I am the master...) the chain of naration of Ahmad is reliable because the author of Jameas sagheer says that the tradition is mutawatir


5) Abu Hamid Ghazzali exp 505 AH

vواجمع الجماهير على متن الحديث من خطبته في يوم عيدير خم باتفاق الجميع وهو يقول : « من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه » فقال عمر بخ بخ يا أبا الحسن لقد أصبحت مولاي ومولى كل مولى فهذا تسليم ورضى وتحكيم ثم بعد هذا غلب الهوى لحب الرياسة وحمل عمود الخلافة وعقود النبوة وخفقان الهوى في قعقعة الرايات واشتباك ازدحام الخيول وفتح الأمصار وسقاهم كأس الهوى فعادوا إلى الخلاف الأول : فنبذوه وراء ظهورهم واشتروا به ثمناً قليلا .

سر العالمين وكشف ما في الدارين ، ج 1 ، ص 13

 And the consensus of the  masses concerning the text of the tradition of Ghadeer from the sermon of the day of Ghadeer is in agreement with all and it is like this " of whomsoever I am the master Ali is his master" then Umar said congratulation congratulations oh Abal Hassan today you have become the master of all the masters and this was submission and satisfaction and judgement but after this his desires overpowered him for the love of kingdom and he then ascribed khilafat for himself, and changed the pillar of khilafat from its original place and with the   means of military and raised the flags and spread it to other frontiers and caused the path of difference for the ummat just like the days of jhahiliyat, and thus became a subject of this verse
They put it (covenant) behind their backs and sold it for a lowly price



 Mulla Ali Qari (exp 1014 AH) 6
vأن هذا حديث صحيح لا مرية فيه ، بل بعض الحفاظ عده متواتراً إذ في رواية أحمد أنه سمعه من النبي9 ثلاثون صحابيا وشهدوا به لعلي لما نوزع أيام خلافته

مرقاة المفاتيح شرح مشكاة المصابيح ، ج 11 ، ص 248
Surely this tradition is reliable there is no doubt in it also some of the traditionalists have recorded it as mutawatir, when we see the tradition from Ahmad being narrated from 30 companions and they testified it for Ali when they were summoned during his khilafat




 Allamah Shamsuddin Jurai Shafeii (exp 833 AH) 7 

vهذا حديث حسن من هذا الوجه ، صحيح من وجوه كثيرة تواتر عن امير المؤمنين علي ، وهو متواتر ايضاً عن النبي9 رواه الجم الغفير عن الجم الغفير ، ولا عبرة بمن حاول تضعيفه من لا اطلاع له في هذا العلم .

 أسني المطالب في مناقب سيدنا علي بن أبي طالب ، ص48
This tradition is good from this aspect and is also reliable to the extent of tawatur from Ali (a.s) and is also mutawatir from the Prophet and is narrated from groups of forgiven ones from the groups of forgiven. And there is no example for the one who considers it weak for him there is no knowledge in this matter


Sibt ibne jauzii (exp 654 AH) 8 
اتّفق علماء السير على أنّ قصّة الغدير كانت بعد رجوع النبي9 من حجّة الوداع في الثامن عشر من ذي الحجّة جمع الصحابة وكانوا مائة وعشرون ألفاً وقال: (من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه) الحديث ، نص9على ذلك بصريح العبارة دون التلويح والإشارة
تذكرة الخواص ، ص 37 
The authors of biography are unanimous that the incident of Ghadeer took place at the return from the hajjatul wida on the 18th Zilhaj. He (sawa) gathered the companions and they were 120000 in number, he (sawa) then said "of whomsoever I am the master then Ali is his master" these are clear traditions that indicate towards  this fact and not just indications  and remarks towards this incident. tazkeratul khwas page 37



Allamah Ismaeel bin muhammed Alajlooni jerahii (exp 1162 AH) 9 

(من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه) رواه الطبراني وأحمد والضياء في المختارة عن زيد بن أرقم وعلي وثلاثين من الصحابة بلفظ اللهم وال من والاه وعاد من عاداه فالحديث متواتر أو مشهور 
 كشف الخفاء ، ج 2 ، ص 361 ، رقم : 2591
 The tradition "of whomsoever I am the master Ali is his master" has been narrated by Ahmad and Ziya on the authority of Zaid bin Arqam and Ali and from 30 companions using the sentence "Oh Allah love the one who loves him and be enemy of the one who is his enemy" then this tradition is mutwatir also famous. Kashfal khafa volume 2 page 361 tradition number 2591



Muhammad bin Ismaeel Sanaanie (exp 1182 AH) 10

حديث من كنت مولاه فعلى مولاه أخرجه جماعة من أئمة الحديث منهم أحمد والحاكم من حديث ابن عباس وابن أبي شيبة وأحمد من حديث ابن عباس عن بريدة وأحمد وابن ماجه عن البراء و ... وقد عده أئمة من المتواتر
 توضيح الأفكار لمعاني تنقيح الأنظار ، ج 1 ، ص 243
The tradition "of whomsoever I am the master Ali is his master" has come from group of Imams of tradition from them are Ahmad and Hakim from the tradition of Ibne Abbas and Ibne Abi Shaibahand Ahmed brings from Ibne Abbas from Buraidah and Ibne Majah from Bura... and from a group of Imams  such that it is mutawatir


Mohammad bin Jafar Alkatani (exp 1345 AH) 11

وفي رواية لأحمد أنه سمعه من النبي9 ثلاثون صحابيا وشهدوا به لعلي لما نوزع أيام خلافته وممن صرح بتواتره أيضا المناوي في التيسير نقلا عن السيوطي وشارح المواهب اللدنية وفي الصفوة للمناوي
 نظم المتناثر من الحديث المتواتر ، ج 1 ، ص 195
And from the tradition of Ahmad surely it has been heard from the Prophet (sawa) from 30 companions and they witnessed it before Ali when they were summoned during his khilafat and it is declared as tawatur also Manawi in tayseer has narrated this from suyuti and Shareh Almawahib addaniyat and in Sifwato of Manawi



Muhammad Nasir Albani (exp 1420 Ah) 12

vو للحديث طرق أخرى كثيرة جمع طائفة كبيرة منها الهيثمي في المجمع و قد ذكرت و خرجت ما تيسر لي منها مما يقطع الواقف عليها بعد تحقيق الكلام على أسانيدها بصحة الحديث يقينا، و إلا فهي كثيرة جدا، و قد استوعبها ابن عقدة في كتاب مفرد، قال الحافظ ابن حجر: منها صحاح و منها حسان.
و جملة القول أن حديث الترجمة حديث صحيح بشطريه ، بل الأول منه متواتر عنه9 كما ظهر لمن تتبع أسانيده و طرقه ، و ما ذكرت منها كفاية
السلسلة الصحيحة ، ج 4 ، ص 249
As for the tradition its chains are numerous amongst which are a group of great scholars like Haisami in majmaa, and indeed he has remembered it and brought it what  made easy for us that which cuts the arguments for the one who investigates into its chains to confirm the reliability of the tradition and except that they are great in numbers and certainly ibne uqdah has exposed these in his book Mufrad, Hafiz ibne Hajar says: amongst it is correct and amongst it are good. And the conclusion of the saying is that the tradition and its meaning are correct in its context as due to the fact of its being mutawatir as it is manifested for the one who investigates its chains and its paths and what has been discussed in Kifayah


Final word: After looking at the comments of the pillars of Ahle Sunnah traditionalists and scholars there remains no doubt that the tradition of Ghadeer is reliable and acceptable and this is definitely a truth that can never be denied by the seeker of truth. Our question to the Muslim ummat is this that why would scholars like Bukhari and Muslim did not deem fit to include such an important tradition? specially when the great scholars of all time have considered it a mutawatir tradition? The answer could only be one of the two options. either their books are incomplete and miss some of the important declarations of Imamat and wilayat of Ahle Bayt (a.s) or they have not dealt the right of Ahle Bayt (a.s) as ought its due. we leave it upto the readers to decide which one is true specially relating the fact that Bukhari has not narrated a single tradition from Imam Baqir (a.s) who was considered at the least an important Tabeieen if at all Bukhari did not know his relation to the Holy Prophet (sawa) but at the same time Bukhari deems fit to narrate traditions from the killer of Imam Hussain (a.s) the accursed Ibne Saad. May Allah Hasten the reappearance of His Last Hujjat (atfs) who takes the revenge of the killing of the grandson of the Holy Prophet (sawa) Ameen! Ameen